Barack Obama and the Guns of September

THE FIFTH COLUMNIST by P.M. Carpenter

God knows Democrats have reason to be neurotic.

After the incompetence of 2004, the theft of 2000, the fecklessness of 1988, the despair of 1984, the mugging of 1980, the near inconceivability of 1972 and the crushing disappointment of 1968, they have acquired a not unreasonable resistance to confidence and aplomb.

Gloominess and foreboding are now part of the Democratic DNA. They smile on occasion, when instructed to smile, but in general they sulk like temperamental, hormonally imbalanced teenagers. Oh Jesus, oh Christ, they brood … we're about to lose another one.

And sure enough, the prevailing environmental winds of 2008 are no damn different.

Yes, of course it's exasperating, even infuriating, that George W. McCain could be running neck and neck in the national polls with any Democratic opponent after eight tormenting years of John S. Bush. After all, in a sane world, even Dennis Kucinich would be running 20 points ahead, and accumulating more every day.

Yet here we are, almost unbelievably, neck and neck indeed. So, predictably, as this two-year presidential campaign stumbles into the final stretches, the Sturm und Drang of Democratic defeatism once again takes center stage.

Look, by nature -- or, as I prefer to believe, by historical training -- I'm a happy cynic and confirmed pessimist. But this time around, anyway, I think that rumors of the Democratic candidate's sure and coming demise are thoughtlessly preceding the reality of the situation.

In the first place, running neck and neck in the national polls barely means a thing. No doubt, the polls are fun and interesting to follow and analyze and either cheer or wring one's hands over, depending on their ascending or descending trend, and in the very broadest sense of analysis they do provide some leading indications. But as the leading indicator of the election's outcome, they suck.

Because, simply, we don't hold a national election for the presidency. That's easy to forget, since people like me tend to belabor the unreal, but at least every now and then, rather than popping another antidepressant we should remind ourselves of the (idiotic) electoral-college basis for electing a president.

And then, having done that, consider this: If Barack Obama were to merely hold on to John Kerry's marvelously blue states of 2004 (and given the almost sclerotic polarization of American politics, there's little reason to doubt he will), but in addition pick up only the state of Ohio -- where he happens to be running somewhat consistently about five points ahead -- then Barack Obama will win.

That, in itself, should facilitate one's easier sleep. But there are other reasons for cautious optimism, as well.

Chief among them is the wretched dyspepsia of Obama's opponents. Hey, they've seen the internal, state-by-state polls, which in turn reflect the handwriting on the walls of at least 20 game-winning states plus the District of Columbia, which in further turn have turned McCain-Palin visibly sour, ill natured and nasty. And the nastier they get, the clearer the evidence of their troubles.

If anything should legitimately worry, it's the presidential debates.

Obama is unsteady, at best, at that particular racket. That's an odd fact of life for such a once-upon-a-time promising law student; he must have been dozing during moot court sessions or worrying about the next edition of the Law Review, but it's a fact nevertheless. Plus, reason, logic and a splendidly argued case in these debates guarantee not a winner, as we know all too depressingly well.

And God forbid he should at any point sigh. Please, please keep that in mind, Sen. Obama -- the future of Christendom and Western Civilization itself hang in your respiratory balance.

But, all that remains to be seen.

What does not remain to be seen any longer, however, is whether Obama intends to do what so many have so adamantly urged him to do: go on the bloody offense.

As the New York Times headlines it today: "Senator Barack Obama will intensify his assault against Senator John McCain … beginning [this] morning…. The new tone is to be presented in a speech by Mr. Obama in New Hampshire and in television interviews with local stations in five swing states, backed up by new advertisements [whose 'themes will be pay equity for women'] and appearances across the country by supporters."

The Obama campaign argues that the fresh offensive was in the works all along -- that in its prescripted playbook was the "strategy that called for a steady escalation of attacks on Mr. McCain as the race heads toward the debates."

Whether it's doing what it's now doing through pressure or premeditation, I frankly couldn't care less. The important thing is, the campaign now clearly plans to finish this contest with guns blazing.

Obama's favorite film is "The Godfather," and in a favorite film is often a key to that person's psyche. Perhaps you recall to what end Michael stealthily lay in wait for his final "counter-argument."

Please respond to P.M.'s commentary by leaving comments below and sharing them with the BuzzFlash community. For personal questions or comments you can contact him at fifthcolumnistmail@gmail.com

THE FIFTH COLUMNIST by P.M. Carpenter

Technorati Tags:

I think you're wrong.

I live in Ohio and can assure you that Obama is not running a consistent 5 points ahead unless you have access to polling data the rest of us don't. Obama is currently (9/13) running 2 points behind McCain and McCain is trending up while Obama is now trending down. Obama has also lost his slight leads in New Mexico and Nevada and McCain is gaining ground in Washington state. Obama is also flat in Pennsylvania and nose diving in Florida. Obama is behind in the daily tracking polls and it now looks like McCain may in fact win and win big. As of today fivethrityeight.com shows McCain with 277 EV's to Obama's 261. A mere two weeks ago Obama had 320 EV's. On Ohio television all I see is McCain/Palin attack ads, it seems they run every 15 minutes. Plus there are puff pieces on McCain Palin on shows like "Inside Edition". Obama's performance on Olbermann was dreadful, uhhs and umms, he sounded too much like a boring college professor. Unless things change quickly in Ohio, Obama will not carry the state and he may lose Pennsylvania as well. So I'm afraid I don't share your optimism. Obama has about 30 days. If he is not ahead in EV's and daily tracking polls by October 15, McCain will run out the clock to victory. Obama better get some renewed energy and start breathing fire. From my vantage point Biden is invisible, Obama is defensive and dull and the Clinton's are non-existent. If any of these people are doing anything, it's not getting any coverage, and that is indeed a shame and a scandal. And as of last week local Obama headquarters (Athens, Ohio home of Ohio University)had no yard signs, bumper stickers or other campaign materials available. What kind of operation is that in a swing state?

You Have More Faith In Obama Than I Have

I have to question whether there is time for Obama to learn how to utilize the fire he has with his prepared speeches when speaking extemporaneously during the debates. His performance on this level is seriously uneven.

For instance, his appearance on last Monday's Countdown was a poor showing for such a fine speaker, and Olbermann's show is very friendly ground. I have read where he did somewhat better on Letterman's show, but that venue is not nearly as important as the debates will be.

It is said that Nixon lost the 1960 debates because of his five-o'clock-shadow. It would be a disaster for the nation and the world if Obama is seen (rightly or wrongly) as being afraid of Palin's shadow. He has to knock McCain out in the first debate, or he plays catch-up the rest of the way to November.

Sheez, about time

I don't know who or what led Obama to believe that he could just unilaterally disarm in the ad wars and actually be given credit for it, either by the media or the electorate. But apparently McCain's last 2 ads have sufficiently chastened and drained him of his last drop of campaign idealism. I say good riddance. Idealism never won an election. Obama should have never quashed the liberal 527's, as they were sure to do most of the dirty work for him. Anyway, get ready for more fake outrage and whining from the McCain campaign as these new hard-hitting ads begin to get under McCain's skin. It'll be great to see the shoe on the other foot for a change.

What a flake!

P.M. Carpenter, you write the stupidest stuff!!!

Brilliant retort

As always. How does McStain taste?