Scott McClellan and the Politics of Profitable Hurt

THE FIFTH COLUMNIST by P.M. Carpenter

Well, former White House press secretary Scott McClellan got the media firestorm he was hoping for, which will make the unemployed propagandist millions of dollars, which, I'm sure, he was hoping for even more.

Old -- sometimes even young -- right wingers never seem to die; they just fade, and not even courteously away, into filthy and immensely undeserved riches.

He's now being offered up by many on the left for political sainthood, because he's perceived as having turned on his old boss (which, according to those who've actually read all of What Happened, isn't quite the case). And that's the sort of Greek political drama we love. It's more than Oedipal, it's tasty.

But lest we forget: If Scottie had not been pushed out of Propaganda Central, he would still be standing there at the White House podium, spewing the vilest of deceptions and lies on behalf of his criminal keepers.

Setting the record straight and reclaiming his credibility, my butt. Truth is, this vengeful turncoat got his feelings hurt, as opposed to losing an arm or a leg or his manhood or his head in a cockeyed war without justification, except from a political marketing point of view.

Watching others suffer those far more monstrous fates was somehow emotionally bearable for Scottie, as long as, that is, he was one of the boys. When his innate incompetence caught up to him, however, and Bush's chief of staff decided to put him out to the pasture in which he had always belonged, what once was bearable became oppressive.

So Scottie got scruples. Along with a nice book contract.

And just "what happened," may I ask, as reported by Scottie not that we didn't already know? Which is to say, what Scottie knew all along? What is it that Scottie learned after leaving the White House that he didn't well know when he was in the White House -- when, that is, he was playing its game, happily attempting mass deception for personal notoriety and a paycheck?

Was he aware of the Iraq war as having been marketed as casually as a new toothpaste? Yep. Was he aware of the White House's "political propaganda" machinery having grievously "manipulat[ed] sources of public opinion"? Yep. Hell, we all were.

Was he aware that his White House comrades had "downplay[ed] the major reason for going to war," which actually was twofold: the idiotic idea of establishing something idiotically called "coercive democracy" in the Middle East, largely for the greater personal glory of President George W. Bush? Yep, and yep.

And when did Scottie do something about all this? While he may not have been in the White House loop that was piecing the bloody and irreversible scam together, he learned of its infrastructure and working details while actively around them.

Yet he did nothing, said nothing, revealed nothing when it might have mattered -- when, as he now writes, the White House was "turn[ing] away from candor and honesty when those qualities were most needed."

If those words hadn't been written by a typically opportunistic right winger, they'd be breathtaking.

One of Scottie's criticisms of Bush is that the president "convinces himself to believe what suits his needs at the moment." You don't say, Mr. McClellan. That trait seems to run in his political family, does it not?

But here's what I know, Scottie. Here's what really happened.

You and your criminal cohort damn near destroyed this nation. I could sit here and write a long list of the hows, whats and whys, but they are too universally known to any longer bother with. By now, virtually everyone knows "what happened," Scottie.

Only a few will profit from it, however. Very few. You were one of the few then, and you're one now.

Congratulations. As others struggle over the next 20 or 30 years to overcome the vast wreckage you helped cause, you'll be sitting pretty. Congratulations, indeed, you criminal ass.

Please respond to P.M.'s commentary by leaving comments below and sharing them with the BuzzFlash community. For personal questions or comments you can contact him at fifthcolumnistmail@gmail.com

THE FIFTH COLUMNIST by P.M. Carpenter

Technorati Tags:

Will He Testify In Court Against Bush And Co-Criminals?

"Even though he's one of them?" "Because he's one of them." "What about his own trial on the charge of having assisted George W. Bush in lying us into war?" "If convicted he could get a reduced sentence for his having been among the first insiders to fess up." "And the rest of them?" "Guilty as charged."

Watching Scottie Crow

I'm just thankful Scottie's taken the headlines away from the dreadful Hillary saga and those freaky polygamist sex scandal women. Eewww!

You're looking a gift horse

You're looking a gift horse in the mouth! Just take the gift. One thing: Scotty oozed and radiated detestation of his job. I doubt he had to be pushed very hard to get out.

Neither shoot nor canonize the messenger

I agree with ERW.
So McClellan's not a hero. So what?
If he'd resigned in protest in 2003 he'd have been excoriated then and nobody would be talking about him now.
I don't know what thumb screws the Bushies put on Paul O'Neill, but he has hardly said a peep
since his as-told-to book with Ron Suskind appeared.

The publication of Scott's book now is more politically useful to the Dems and all Bush opponents than
it would have been a few years ago.

Look on the bright side. The news is not what he wrote but that he wrote.
And if he makes money selling his book that means some will be reading it.

Somebody might usefully do some reporting on the McClellan family. I believe they're
a well connected Republican family in Texas. Scott's brother Mark ran the FDA and then Medicare, 2002-2006, according to Wikipedia. Now he's at Brookings. One wonders if the family has had
some kind of falling out with the Bushes. It would be interesting to know if there's a story
there.

Colleen Clark
Cambridge, MA

I commend Scott McClellan

I commend Scott McClellan for being the deft, and necessarily cynical, Republican he has proven himself to be. As ERW says below, he's not telling us anything others haven't shouted from the rooftops without much effect. So what does Scottie have?

A perfect opportunity to make oodles of money.

I wouldn't be surprised if his erstwhile colleagues aren't privately giving him the thumbs up for taking advantage of the situation by nailing it right in the sweet spot.

And if Bushie gives the defense industry a boost by launching a few cruise missiles at Iran, McClellan will get to write another book titled something like: "Wow! You People Sure Are Stupid!"

It'll be fun watching the pond ripple for a while. Then, of course, nothing will happen.

Not for Wexler's lack of trying though.

Hmmm. Maybe Scottie has realized he was used like a cheap whore.

His "Doh!" moment.

What Scott has now is --- negative approval ratings

When Scott was standing at the podium at White House Press Corps briefings, Bush had high approval ratings. The White House Press Corps was laughing at Bush's jokes, at dinners, about "oh - where are those WMD's -- I know they are around here somewhere." The White House Press Corps was singing and dancing with Karl Rove. (And they were sitting on their hands, when Steven Colbert told them what good stenographers they were.) Then, the pendulum swung the other way. Iraq became our worst nightmare. Bush's approval ratings are in the tank. And 68% of us think this war, that Scott McClellan helped sell us, was a mistake. Timing, like location, is everything.

Greedy jerk

I just saw poor Scott on TV. He wrote the book for the good of the country, not to get rich. Yeah, right. I didn't believe the lies he was spewing from his White House podium and I have no reason to believe the revelations in his book. The only thing that's changed is that he's got a fat book contract now instead of a paycheck.

This jerk should not be rewarded for talking now. He should have been spilling the beans when it mattered and he could have done some good. That couldn't happen then because he couldn't cash in then. DON'T BUY HIS BOOK! If you want to read it, get it at a library or buy it used. Don't pad that criminal's bank account.

No need to buy the book. We

No need to buy the book. We know how it ends.

Its as if Benedict Arnold...

...changed his mind and returned to the Continental Army, not safe shoes to fill! Scottie is facing a firestorm, and one he deserves. But we on the left should give him some breathing room through this long news cycle, to encourage him to spill a few more beans, if possible. While he is not revealing anything that was not already known, his assertions carry more weight with the MSM than the "left blogo-sphere". Scottie was Shrub's boy, which is why the full court press of Shrub's administration is trashing him with the same talking points. I love watching their panic! Lord knows America needs other "Scotties" to emerge from under their rocks to support claims of high crimes and misdemeanors. My lord, Rupert ‘FOX NEWS’ Murdock is quoted today as saying that Barack will win the election and that he love's what he has to say?!! I think we may be seeing some serious re-alignment here and the opportunity for Congress to take some names and addresses, so to speak!

Scottie is just another Dumbyass Dirtbag

PM, you hit the nail on the head. If Scottie had an ounce of humanity, he would be working to assemble the evidence for John Conyers to send Dumbyass and his band of thugs to jail for a long, long time. Scottie is just another Dumbyass Dirtbag, JMHO.

Nobody believed those who did speak out

Remember Richard Clarke? Rember Paul O'Neill? Remember Joe Wilson? Remember "State of Denial" - Bob Woodward? Phil Donohue? Bill Maher? Nobody believed them at the time they spoke out. Nothing changed. Bush was re-elected. Could Scott McClellan, adding his voice to those who did speak out, have changed anything? I doubt he could have. Bob Woodward didn't speak out until he got a book deal. He still works at The Washington Post. There is an old Indian Prayer "Grant that I May Not Criticize My Neighbor, Until I Have Walked a Mile In His Moccasins." The indignation is righteous, P.M. Most of us feel it. But -- aren't we shooting the messenger?

You make an excellent point

However, I'm not sure the main point is whether or not the country would have believed him had he spoken out earlier--it may not have, as your examples suggest--but whether he could have retained a modicum of dignity by doing what was ethical at the time rather than simply cashing a paycheck on the backs of our war-dead and furthering his career. It now looks like he is attempting to have it both ways...soothing his battered conscience, settling old scores, and yes, cashing in yet again while doing so. You're absolutely right, he may not have changed anything by speaking out or simply resigning at the time, but don't personal ethics and all that is holy scream out that he at least should have tried?

Nailed it

With one caveat--who are these people on the Left offering Scottie up for canonization? I'm sure they exist, but I must read ten lefty blogs a day and I haven't seen any evidence of it. Most of us on this side know exactly who McClellan is and what he did and what he's doing now, and I just don't see a lot of people (outside the media) being fooled. I believe it's more of a false meme being furthered by the likes of Ari Fleicher and Karl Rove--"many on the left are embracing Scott now but they'll throw him under the bus when it's convenient." Well, as far as I can tell his ass is already under the bus, where it belongs. People like Rove and Fleischer never waste an opportunity to further a false, anti-democratic meme so we have to be careful not to buy into it. A minor point, perhaps, considering the excellence of the rest of the post, but one worth considering.

I couldn't agree more...

... and when they hopefully try this lot for treason and war crimes, dearest Scotty will be among those tried, convicted, and hung. What a piece of filth.

You nailed it.

What astounded me was the attention given to a book of crap that we already know. The MSM seems more shocked and appalled at the scrutiny given to them by this douche than by anything war or Plame related. THEY WERE ALL IN ON IT!!! That's why it's so weird to see all the pundits jibber-jabbering as if it's news. Pathetic.

Absolutely

I mean, look at what the asshole had to say! He didn't REVEAL anything. "It's the first time when I felt I was witnessing Bush convincing himself to believe something that probably was not true, and that, deep down, he knew was not true..." - Are you fucking kidding me? You don't convince yourself to believe something that isn't true Scottie. The reality is called lying for political expediency. What a worthless prick. I'm truly astounded that this little dirtbag will end up as just another war profiteer.